Wandler loses copyright infringement lawsuit against Loewe over Ida handbag

Amsterdam-based bag brand Wandler has been unsuccessful in its copyright infringement case against Spanish fashion house Loewe. The District Court of Amsterdam ruled that Loewe’s Whisker bag does not infringe upon Wandler’s copyright, despite similarities to the Dutch brand’s Ida bag. This follows a ruling issued on November 11, 2026.

Wandler argued that the Whisker, which Loewe presented in March 2026 during Paris Fashion Week, bears too close a resemblance to the Ida bag. According to the Amsterdam brand, the combination of various design features was copied. The Ida first went on sale in July 2025 and is one of the brand’s most successful designs, according to Wandler.

The judge acknowledged that the combination of ten design choices on the Ida bag is protected by copyright. According to the preliminary relief judge, this combination reflects the personality of the designer. The individual elements do not all need to be independently protected for this to apply. Furthermore, the judge considered it unlikely that Loewe was entirely unaware of Wandler’s existence, given the publicity surrounding the brand and the presence of both labels at various points-of-sale.

Nevertheless, the judge ruled that there is no copyright infringement. Although the bags resemble each other from certain angles, Loewe has given the shared design elements its own creative execution. Consequently, the Whisker possesses its own original character. Wandler’s request to ban the sale of the bag in the Netherlands was rejected.

Wandler Ida handbag (left) and Loewe Whisker Bag (right). Credits: Wandler

Counterclaim by Loewe rejected

In turn, Loewe argued that Wandler had taken inspiration for the Ida bag from earlier designs by the Spanish fashion house. The counterclaim focused, among other things, on the zip strip of the Ida.

This claim was also rejected. According to the judge, sufficient independent creative choices were made in the execution of the zip strip, including the overhang, the arch and the rounded ends. This constitutes an independently protected design.

The judge rejected the provisional measures requested by both parties. Wandler must pay Loewe’s legal costs, which amount to 2,101 euros.

Wandler considers appeal

Wandler described the ruling as a mixed outcome. The brand is pleased that the judge deemed the combination of ten design choices in the Ida bag to be protected by copyright, yet it disagrees with the conclusion that Loewe did not commit an infringement. “We believe that the similarities in the combination of the relevant design choices should have carried more weight in the assessment of the copyright infringement,” Joost Doeswijk, CEO of Wandler, told FashionUnited.

Wandler also noted that the rejection of Loewe’s counterclaim is significant. “The fact that the judge rejected the counterclaim regarding the zip strip confirms for us that the design of the Ida is sufficiently distinctive and original.”

The brand is currently reviewing the ruling with its legal advisers. “We are looking into what next steps are possible, including an appeal. No final decision has been made on this yet,” said Doeswijk. According to Wandler, the ruling has no consequences for the sale or further development of the Ida bag. “The bag remains part of our collection.”


OR CONTINUE WITH
Accessories
Loewe
Wandler